Each round a rotating Judge reads a multiple choice trivia question from one of the 6 trivia categories. The remaining players answer secretly using their ABC response cards.

Without saying the answers, the remaining players take turns trying to convince the Judge that they answered correctly. They must explain how or why they know the answer…even if they're completely clueless! The other players can trash talk in an attempt to cast doubt on each other.

The Judge interrogates the other players to try to figure out who actually knows the answer and who's only pretending to know. The Brilliant Card goes to one player the Judge believes chose the correct answer while the BS Card goes to one player they believe chose the wrong answer.

The player who receives the Brilliant Card earns points for convincing the Judge even if they answered incorrectly. All players earn points for correct answers. After everyone reveals their answers, the Judge earns points for correct predictions and loses points for incorrect predictions.